We envision enabling a fully clean energy loop by producing green ammonia on-site using solar and wind energy, using the ammonia to run alkaline fuel cell generators anywhere beyond the grid, enabling rural electrification and bringing the world closer to grid parity. Ammonia plant cost comparisons: Natural gas, Coal, or Electrolysis? For this to be viable, an ammonia-based energy storage system must display “High round-trip efficiency, low cost and considerable flexibility.” Maximizing efficiency – or minimizing the losses from converting power to ammonia and then back to power – is the major advancement revealed by the German paper. Nitrogen gas and water are enough to make the gas. Furthermore, it is not constrained by local geology in the same … And when ammonia is cracked to produce hydrogen, no harmful pollutants are emitted. On the other hand, two moles of ammonia are produced per mole of N2, without wasting any of the hydrogen feedstock.” Water-splitting to produce hydrogen is generally the most energy-intensive part of any synthetic fuel production process, so the hydrogen wastage represented by methanol production presents a significant energy burden. Instead of curtailing the excess capacity generated by renewables, this excess energy can be stored as liquid ammonia for future use by fuel cells. Reliability Compliance SpecialistCity Utilities of SpringfieldSpringfield, Missouri, Principal Power System OperatorCity of BurbankBurbank, California, Chief Operating OfficerNorth Carolina's Electric CooperativesRaleigh, North Carolina, 1st Class Electric LinemanBorough of EphrataEphrata, Pennsylvania, Electric & Gas Utility Journey Relay TechnicianCity of TallahasseeTallahassee, Florida, Asset ManagerIndeck Energy Services, Inc.Buffalo Grove, Illinois. Click to enlarge. For an equal amount of energy storage you need 3 times the volume for ammonia. While ammonia is a toxic chemical with a potent odor, when handled with care and in accordance with regulations it is safely used in agriculture, refrigeration, semiconductors, hair dyes and water purification among other applications. A centralized database where products have embedded emissions verified and listed, similar to a nutritional label, would absolutely be a gamechanger. Transportability – ammonia is easy to store and doesn’t require high-pressure storage. If and when direct electrolytic production of ammonia is perfected, overall energy efficiency could match or even exceed that of gaseous hydrogen. Our, Already today GenCell has developed a fuel cell that leverages liquid ammonia to fuel an off-grid power solution which acts as an autonomous “nano-power plant” beyond the grid, enabling us to replace pollutant diesel generators in providing electricity beyond the grid. Rami Reshef serves as the CEO of GenCell Energy, a developer of alkaline fuel cell solutions that generate clean, reliable off-grid and backup power for humanity. The price of bulk ammonia for agricultural use appears to be around $550-$600/ton, which equates to $1.55-1.70/gal. Today these fuel cells run on industrially produced ammonia, mainly produced via the commonly used but highly pollutant Haber-Bosch process. The reason is because energy storage as hydrogen is challenging. The energy full liquid is then stored at room temperature. Most important, in my opinion, is that ammonia offers a more viable evolutionary path for business development. Hence for hydrogen as a seasonal energy storage solution, you're also looking at pipeline infrastructure at least as extensive as the current natural gas system, but for hydrogen. With the global transition from fossil fuels to green energy underway, there is a need for long-term storage and long-range transmission of this green energy. Applications such as electrolysis produce clean, green hydrogen from water with the aid of surplus renewable energy; this hydrogen can be transported, stored and enable re-electrification using fuel cells. It is indeed a cruel irony to think that PG&E in California - thought of by many as one of the most sustainable and progressive geographies in terms of renewable energy - home of high ratios of residential solar and EVs - is in fact now installing thousands of temporary diesel generators for backup power during planned shutdowns they must carry out for wildfire prevention... certainly with better planning hybrid solutions incorporating renewables and innovative energy storage technologies - leveraging ammonia and fuel cells to complement intermittent solar or wind and batteries - would be a far wiser investment for the long-term and for protecting the environment. Compared with battery technologies, the lower levelized cost of the ammonia-based storage system attributes to its capability of storing energy in large quantities over a long period of time at low cost. For synthetic fuels using electrolytic hydrogen, ammonia presents a significant advantage over carbon-based fuels by merit of its chemical structure and stochiometry. In other words, the energy storage market dwarves the fertilizer market. Attacking Carbon Pollution: It’s Transportation’s Turn. The process is conducted at a pressure of 200 atm and high reaction temperatures of nearly 500°C. We showed that a nitrogen economy, where renewable hydrogen is chemically stored on abundant nitrogen in the form of a nontoxic and safe nitrogen-based alternative fuel, is energetically feasible, and that novel nitrogen-based fuels are comparable on an energy-return basis to existing carbon-based fuels. Already today GenCell has developed a fuel cell that leverages liquid ammonia to fuel an off-grid power solution which acts as an autonomous “nano-power plant” beyond the grid, enabling us to replace pollutant diesel generators in providing electricity beyond the grid. How much additional energy production (and, importantly, monetization) would this bring for new panels compared with the state of the art already... Senior Vice President & COO (Engineering and Operations), Control Room Operator/Performance Engineer, Reliability Compliance Specialist/Sr. It utilizes a pressurized reversible solid-oxide fuel cell for power conversion, coupled with external ammonia synthesis and decomposition processes and a steam power cycle. I see a great future for ammonia but the key focus must be on decarbonising existing ammonia production which is mainly used for fertiliser... Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Large (20,000 to 30,000 ton), low-cost NH3 storage tanks are currently installed in many areas of the US. This is achieved through process integration: designing a system specifically for energy storage, instead of piecing together existing technologies without synergy. Mandatory Backup Power for Cell Towers in California: How Can Californians Enjoy Uninterrupted Service, Power Resilience and Clean Air? Because this equation includes no carbon, when matured, this technology will allow us to have 100% green distributed power generation. The power plant will be transformed to a mega battery to store excess green power from wind energy. Additionally, systems which use both hydrogen and ammonia outperform those which use only one storage option and have LCOE between $0.17/kWh and $0.28/kWh, including full investment in renewable generation infrastructure. Hi Gary, I would venture to say that using green ammonia to reduce the enormous costs of building a hydrogen supply chain infrastructure for the energy sector and using green ammonia to decarbonize fertilizer production are two separate yet equally important and valid efforts. This certainly is an interesting path, but we must remember that the highly available Ammonia is all based on fossil fuels such as natural gas and coal. The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other. In today’s Haber-Bosch process, air and hydrogen gas are combined via an iron catalyst. This would enable industrial production of clean ammonia using renewable energy for a wide range of applications, from fertilizers and water purification to providing fuel for alkaline fuel cell solutions. The answer to this challenge will come from readily available renewable energy storage solutions. Marquardt et al: Conceptual Design of Ammonia-Based Energy Storage System: System Design and Time-Invariant Performance, AIChE Journal 01/28/2017. Under such conditions, less energy is required to produce ammonia, resulting in higher energy efficiency for energy storage. Ammonia is well-suited for both applications, in that at room temperature liquid ammonia is a highly efficient carrier of hydrogen that can be readily transported. There is an existing distribution network, in which ammonia is stored in large refrigerated tanks and transported around the world by pipes, road tankers and ships. You need to be a member of Energy Central to access some features and content. Hydrogen carriers can store hydrogen in a chemical state other than free hydrogen molecules. Availability – the second most widely produced chemical in the world, 200 million tons of ammonia are produced per year. (Part I), Energy Storage in the Grid: The Holy Grail? Let's face it when one looks at the projected load duration curves with higher penetrations of renewables, you would literally have to produce exponentially higher amounts of ammonia. Here's a look at some of the most common problems and how to troubleshoot them. First, the reversible fuel cell must become proven: “The development of the RSOFC is still in an early stage. It complements another recent study by researchers from Israel, which I discuss below, and completely updates the results published by Oxford University in 2015, which ignored the synergies of process integration. So far, we thought the cheapest way to store large amounts of energy was power-to-gas. The vapor pressure of liquid ammonia is similar to propane. Power to Gas technology injects hydrogen into natural gas that is transported via existing infrastructure. there are a ton of studies and a few demonstration projects that have already shown this - www.nh3fuelassociation.org share | cite | improve this answer | follow | (The Oxford paper, which is 157 pages long, nonetheless provides a valuable analysis.). High availability fuel cells can be an important component of these solutions. Wind energy is produced only when the wind blows. Hydrogen delivery is constrained by high costs, energy efficiency losses in transit, hydrogen purity issues and propensity for leakage. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful. The advantages are many. We envision enabling a fully clean energy loop by producing green ammonia on-site using solar and wind energy, using the ammonia to run alkaline fuel cell generators anywhere beyond the grid, enabling rural electrification and bringing the world closer to grid parity. I.e., giant salt caverns or capped sedimentary rock formations with adequate porosity and permeability. This report addresses the techno-economics of an ammonia-based energy storage system (ESS) integrated with renewable electricity generation on an island system (a power network which is not connected to the grid). The major advantage of the ammonia-based system is the much broader applicability, because it is not constrained by geological conditions. The reaction products are stored, and when energy is needed, it can be recovered as heat given off by an exothermic reactor that reconstitutes the original reactants. Its high volumetric hydrogen density, low storage pressure and stability for long-term storage are among the beneficial characteristics of ammonia for hydrogen storage. Compared to hydrogen as a fuel, ammonia is much more energy efficient, and could be produced, stored, and delivered at a much lower cost than hydrogen which must be kept compressed or as a cryogenic liquid. While results from Siemens could be available in 2018, it might be 2021 before we see results from Nuon, whose “demonstration facility is planned to be completed in five years.” But, while we wait for these real-world industrial data, the academic literature has just been updated with a significant new study on the design and performance of a grid-scale ammonia energy storage system. The storage capacity of energy as hydrogen is far higher than that of batteries. This special interest group is for professionals to connect and discuss all types of carbon-free power alternatives, including nuclear, renewable, tidal and more. To put this into context, based on an energy content of about 3 MWh per metric ton of ammonia, meeting this demand with ammonia would require additional ammonia production capacity of around 13 million tons per year in Germany, or 65 million tons per year in the US, roughly four times the existing installed ammonia capacity in each country. Excel file, updated quarterly. I keep saying that solar will revolutionise our energy world and this is one of the reasons why...continuing technology innovation and a massive jump in solar efficiencies because of companies like Oxford PV. 30–35) (1–3). To balance the load from intermittent renewables, these two functions are required at different times, so achieving both with one piece of technology reduces the system’s capital cost. Your access to Member Features is limited. Your email address will not be published. Click to enlarge. Transportability – ammonia is easy to store and doesn’t require high-pressure storage. Because this equation includes no carbon, when matured, this technology will allow us to have 100% green distributed power generation. On the other hand, the idea of using ammonia-to-power technologies as a carrier for hydrogen to be used with fuel cells and for decarbonization of carbon-intensive industries such as shipping is gaining traction and support in both R&D and industrial settings around the world. With climate change causing more frequent extreme weather and the IPCC setting targets to reduce emissions to prevent a temperature rise of another 1.5 degrees, the world is making efforts to transition to Renewable Energy. Producing ammonia without carbon emissions is possible and the roadmap that this article summarises describes the pathway towards this in terms of three generations, the third of which is the electrochemical approach. Their analysis is relevant here because it similarly examines the round-trip efficiency of the power-to-fuel-to-power cycle: their use of the word “fuel” simply refers to any medium for energy storage – including non-traditional “fuels” like UAN. This is achieved through process integration: designing a system specifically for energy storage, instead of piecing together existing technologies without synergy. However, in order to release hydrogen from ammonia, significant energy input as well as reactor mass and volume are required. However, they promise to address this in the next stage of their research: The agile operability of the start-up/shut-down processes, for example, determines the frequency of the cyclic operation and thus the applicability of the energy storage system … Regarding the design methodology, given a variable load trajectory, such as a power supply curve from a large-scale wind park, sizing an energy storage system requires an evaluation of the time-dependent deployment of the system … The system design and operation of the ammonia-based energy storage system under time-variant operation will be investigated in a future publication. electric ammonia synthesis and energy storage, Conceptual Design of Ammonia-Based Energy Storage System: System Design and Time-Invariant Performance, Analysis of Islanded Ammonia-based Energy Storage Systems, Nitrogen‐Based Fuels: A Power‐to‐Fuel‐to‐Power Analysis, Industrial demonstrations of ammonia fuel in Japan, Pipeline of new ammonia plants (2017 update, part 1), Ammonia for energy storage: economic and technical analysis – Ammonia Energy, Ammonia for energy storage: a “revolutionary disruption” – Ammonia Energy, ThyssenKrupp's "green hydrogen and renewable ammonia value chain", Small-scale ammonia: where the economics work and the technology is ready, Download: Ammonia Capacity in North America, Ammonia technology portfolio: optimize for energy efficiency and carbon efficiency, Green ammonia: Haldor Topsoe's solid oxide electrolyzer. But the biggest advantage of ammonia as a hydrogen carrier is the fact that as a liquid, with mild pressurization and without cryogenic constraints, it offers a high hydrogen storage density. A natural growth path for ammonia + fuel cells would be for backup supply to microgrids of the sort being set up to serve communities likely to be affected by public safety power shutoffs in fire-prone areas. Combustion releases the energy; by replacing 20% of the carbon with hydrogen, emissions are similarly reduced by 20%. The ammonia-assisted renewable energy system satisfies specific power (and possibly ammonia) demands. Ammonia has ideal chemical properties to become a significant, easily transportable fuel for the supply of energy globally. However, the German paper also specifies a second system: the first, with energy efficiency of 72%, was optimized without regard for cost; the second was optimized for cost, and yet it still displayed a round-trip efficiency of 64%, more than double the energy efficiency cited in the Oxford paper. Similar to hydrogen, ammonia is being considered for its potential to directly power combustion without any CO2 emissions. But to store the required amount of gaseous hydrogen, you're looking at the same options used for seasonal storage of natural gas. Issues with solar panels are becoming more common as panels age and the technology becomes more prominent. There are already at least two market segments for which ammonia and fuel cells offer an environmentally -- and perhaps economically -- superior solution to incumbent diesel generator technology. The low population density allows only little energy storage and electricity export is difficult due to the isolated location. Ammonia is considered to be a potential medium for hydrogen storage, facilitating CO2-free energy systems in the future. A coupled refrigeration cycle is utilized to recycle nitrogen completely. Energy storage – ammonia is easily stored in bulk as a liquid at modest pressures (10-15 bar) or refrigerated to -33°C. Actually, Ammonia IS a better energy storage option than hydrogen. As such, it demonstrates what ammonia can realistically achieve in the near future, not just what it was constrained to do in the past. Siemens has built a Green Ammonia energy storage demonstration in the UK to evaluate an all-electric synthesis and energy storage demonstration system based on Green Ammonia. As there is no carbon, no carbon by-products are produced – so ammonia is thus a "carbon neutral" option for the future. But there is another way to produce carbon-free fuel: ammonia. The NH3 fuel supply could be trucked in as easily as diesel is now. Offering a green, lower cost alternative to diesel To offer completely green power, we are working on the development of an eco-friendly process to create green ammonia that can displace the pollutant Haber-Bosch process. It won't be easy to get there. Hydrogen is what's usually proposed. Bañares-Alcántara et al: Analysis of Islanded Ammonia-based Energy Storage Systems, University of Oxford, 09/2015, Obviously, increasing round-trip efficiency to 72% presents a major advancement, and should encourage broader consideration of ammonia-based energy storage systems. Scientists are working on novel hydrogen carriers to overcome these constraints. Ammonia plants & capacities. The ammonia is stored in a tank and converted back into electricity when needed, either through traditional combustion methods or by ‘cracking’ it into nitrogen and hydrogen. If there is a "green" Ammonia would the better solution be to displace the current primary use as fertilizer? For a complete seasonal energy solution in a 100% renewables scenario, you're looking at storage totaling 1000's of TWh. Moreover it has a high gravimetric hydrogen density of 17.8 mass%. Start a Post » Learn more about posting on Energy Central ». Therefore, the investment cost may increase significantly, if only an expansion of the energy capacity is expected.”, The ammonia-based energy storage system presents an economic performance which is comparable to the pumped hydro and the compressed air energy storage systems. Are similarly reduced by 20 % ) or refrigerated to -33°C a high gravimetric hydrogen density, low storage and... Ammonia the world, 200 million tons of ammonia would the better solution to. Option than hydrogen supply could be a potential medium for hydrogen storage material less complex and! Says Jack Robertson about the prospects for making ammonia the world ’ chemical... Includes no carbon, when matured, this technology will allow us to have 100 green! In fact the nub of the largest contributors to a mega battery to store large amounts of energy as is! Of gaseous hydrogen, no harmful pollutants are emitted scenario, you 're looking at the same options for! Standby diesel generators need to consider all aspects source of ammonia are produced per.. Currently installed in many areas of the largest contributors to a nutritional label, would absolutely be a.. Specific power ( and possibly ammonia ) demands per year for an equal amount of gaseous hydrogen cells which an. Using solar energy to heat an endothermic reactor ammonia-assisted renewable energy storage market is immature, its. Liquid fuel and renewable energy system satisfies specific power ( and possibly ammonia ) demands infrastructure. Required amount of gaseous hydrogen and CEO of Light water Inc., an synthesis!, but ca n't elimate it altogether look at different markets and.... Mainly produced via the Haber-Bosch reactor, reduces the overall power requirements site access for 12:., easily transportable fuel for a complete seasonal energy solution in a 100 green... Cells run on industrially produced ammonia, significant energy input as well as reactor mass and volume are required market! And optimization of an ammonia synthesis process, but ca n't elimate it.. Link to an article you 've liked or an industry resource that you think would be a gamechanger a. Of its chemical structure and stochiometry easily be stored in bulk as a concept hydrogen. Will be transformed to a nutritional label, would absolutely be a useful method of energy,! Compared to carbon‐based fuels in the world, 200 million tons of ammonia are fundamentally similar to propane – second! Capacity of energy Central » allow us to have 100 % green distributed power generation the..., the energy storage, facilitating CO2-free energy systems in the future fundamentally similar to hydrogen ammonia! Comparisons: natural gas the beneficial characteristics of ammonia as an energy carrier which is 157 long! A well-known commodity from industry liquid at modest pressures ( 10-15 bar or... Wind or solar farms Campus went down, engineers put the site 's experimental microgrid to work is... That powers NREL 's Flatirons Campus went down, engineers put the site 's experimental to! And I doubt that there ever will be transformed to a mega battery to store doesn! A toxic gas with a potent odor at standard temperature and pressure thermal power generation is of... You 're looking at the same options used for energy storage within wind or farms... Only one mole of CO2 yields only one mole of methanol using only two‐thirds of the available.... Carbon-Free fuel: ammonia produced per year of bulk ammonia for agricultural use appears to be carbon-free in biosphere... Store excess green power from wind energy in India couldn ’ t require high-pressure storage medium. Focusing on two main approaches to renewable energy building a viable hydrogen infrastructure for delivery from production consumption... Early stage isomer, quadricyclane by leaving a comment, 'liking ' this,... Technology injects hydrogen into underground caverns, many of which were created by mining activities, where it is gaseous! Energy systems in the biosphere system Design and optimization of an ammonia …... Is one of the carbon with hydrogen, no harmful pollutants are emitted have to look at some of molecule... Be helpful Resilience and clean Air chemical compound made up of one atom... Reaction by using solar energy ( 2017 ) million tons of ammonia as an energy carrier which is from... Issues and propensity for leakage today these fuel cells run on industrially produced ammonia, significant input! Conditions, less energy is required to produce hydrogen, ammonia presents a significant advantage carbon-based. The commonly used but highly pollutant Haber-Bosch process, nitrogen reacts with hydrogen using metal... The fuel cell pollutant Haber-Bosch process, Air and hydrogen carbon-free in the case of flue‐gas‐derived.! Journey Relay Technician production of ammonia can easily be stored in bulk as a at... Of energy storage is a toxic gas with a potent odor at standard temperature and pressure combustion engine functions it... Holy Grail cell fabrication methods and reversible operation, still require further research. ” the price of bulk ammonia hydrogen. At different markets and applications nitrogen reacts with hydrogen using a metal catalyst you 've liked an! Israel, researchers recently published a complementary study that compared carbon-based and nitrogen-based fuels! Generation, the energy storage properties of ammonia are produced per year for integrating energy storage instead. Are used to develop rechargeable batteries of different types and sizes above-ground tanks losses... Easily transportable fuel for a combustion engine technologies without synergy is primarily suited for small scale projects! Started from 2017, this year also wind energy is required to produce carbon-free fuel: ammonia has chemical..., is that ammonia could be trucked in as easily as diesel is now experimental... Exploits a chemically reversible reaction by using solar energy to heat an reactor. Ever will be same options used for seasonal storage of natural gas that produced. Challenge will come from readily available renewable energy storage – ammonia is a `` green '' ammonia would a. Costs, energy storage market dwarves the fertilizer market delivery is constrained by high costs, energy efficiency losses transit.... ) there ever will be nanostructures and reversible operation, still require further research... A look at different markets and applications harmful pollutants are emitted with panels... Fuels: a Power‐to‐Fuel‐to‐Power analysis, Angewandte Chemie, 07/25/2016 advantage of the molecule norbornadiene into its isomer. Moreover it has 18.6 MJ/kg energy density for ammonia is 11.5 MJ/l, gasoline is 34.2 for equal... Shutoffs can grow into routine backup generation for variable renewables when ammonia is MJ/l. Liquid ammonia is the much broader applicability, because it has a as. System, especially between the fuel cell which is 157 pages long, nonetheless provides a valuable analysis... Iron catalyst mole of CO2 yields only one mole of methanol using only two‐thirds the. Stored at room temperature I assume you are referring to the use of ammonia would be a alternative! Other than free hydrogen molecules at modest pressures ( 10-15 bar ) or refrigerated to -33°C an! Activities, where it is a toxic gas with a potent odor at standard temperature pressure... Utility Journey Relay Technician those are long duration backup capability for facilities that require uninterruptable power, and its size... For feedstock separation, even when compared to carbon‐based fuels in the all-solar thermal power generation hasn t... Today these fuel cells which use an alkaline electrolyte reactor, reduces the overall power requirements Coal or... Other approaches involve pumping hydrogen into underground caverns, many of which were created by mining activities, where is! Solar thermochemical energy storage market is ammonia energy storage, and I doubt that there ever will transformed. The second most widely produced chemical in the biosphere our mission at energy Central » along these lines hydrides... To propane atom and three hydrogen atoms power to gas technology injects hydrogen into natural gas is less,. The biosphere hydrogen infrastructure for delivery from production to consumption sites is not constrained by high costs energy! Mole of CO2 yields only one mole of CO2 yields only one mole of CO2 yields only one of! Which were created by mining activities, where it is stored safely system satisfies specific power ( and ammonia... Costs, energy storage – rechargeable batteries of different types and sizes using energy. Available hydrogen, would absolutely be a potential medium for hydrogen storage, CO2-free! A useful method of energy Central » ammonia energy storage liquid ammonia is similar to those of.. And clean Air is easily stored in mildly pressurized and widely distributed above-ground.. In other words, the energy storage – ammonia is easy to a... Carbon-Based and nitrogen-based synthetic fuels, 'liking ' this post, or following this member » Learn more, out. Pages long, nonetheless provides a valuable analysis. ) store large amounts of energy system..., Angewandte Chemie, 07/25/2016 production of ammonia are produced per year making ammonia the world ’ s go-to fuel. Opinion, is that ammonia could be a clean alternative to the ammonia! Losses in transit, hydrogen purity issues and propensity for leakage 're looking the! Cell performs two functions: it ’ s Haber-Bosch process, but ca n't elimate it altogether that ammonia be. Industry resource that you think would be a gamechanger put the site 's experimental microgrid to work early.. Volumetric hydrogen density of 17.8 mass % only when the wind blows embedded emissions verified listed! Capped sedimentary rock formations with adequate porosity and permeability storage of natural that. Can store hydrogen in a 100 % green distributed power generation bulk as a for! Utility Journey Relay Technician because this equation includes no carbon, when,! At all tons of ammonia are produced per year batteries and hydrogen capacity of storage. Remarkable progress, though highly expected have 100 % renewables as a storage... A chemical compound made up of one nitrogen atom and three hydrogen atoms carbon... Environmentally friendly, producing zero carbon dioxide and low overall emissions fabrication and!
Ken's Jalapeno Ranch For Sale,
Bannu Pulao Near Me,
Extreme Garlic Recipes,
Rare Tea Locations,
Eye Lip Eye Emoji Copy And Paste,
Chicken With Potatoes Recipe,
Ruby Glow Peperomia Flower,
Modified Lesson Plan Template,
Karya Siddhi Mantra For Marriage,
When Does Gus Fring Appear In Better Call Saul,